Fletcher Bay & Island Center Neighborhood Overview

This corner of Bainbridge Island combines serene waterfront living on Fletcher Bay with the rural-centered charm of Island Center. Homes here enjoy a mix of forested acreage, gently rolling hills, and protected shoreline. Fletcher Bay’s calm inlet offers spectacular sunsets over the Olympic Mountains, while the adjacent Island Center provides a sense of community rooted in nature, agrarian heritage, and accessible local amenities.

Although many of the homes feel secluded, residents are just a short drive from Winslow and other key island hubs — giving the area a perfect balance of peaceful retreat and practical convenience.

The neighborhood’s real estate is highly desirable: luxury single-family homes, often with water access or large lots, dominate the market. Many homes were built in the late 20th century (1970–1999), and the community is comprised of professionals, executives, and remote workers.

Fletcher Bay itself is accessible by boat only at mid to high tide and features a protected waterfront with docks for private use. Its tranquil waters make it ideal for kayaking or paddleboarding, especially in the long summer evenings. The Fletcher Bay Mart & Gas Station and a beloved Thai restaurant (Sawatdy Thai) serve as a convenient local center.

📍 Points of Interest in & Around Fletcher Bay / Island Center

• ⛵ Fletcher Bay Waterfront — Protected inlet, private docks, and stunning sunset views.

• 🏪 Fletcher Bay Mart & Gas Station — A rare convenience in this rural part of the island.

• 🍜 Sawatdy Thai Cuisine — Local favorite for Thai food, right near Fletcher Bay.

• 🌱 Bainbridge Gardens — Nearby garden center offering plants, garden décor, and community charm.

• 🐾 PAWS Adoption Center & Dog-Friendly Spots — Part of the community fabric around Island Center.

• 🌲 Grand Forest Trails — Easy access to the island’s lush forest trail network from Island Center.

• 🏞️ Strawberry Hill Park — Includes soccer fields, picnic space, a skate park, and more in Island Center.

• 🪨 Frog Rock — A playful glacial erratic, popular local landmark and cycling regroup point.

🎓 Schools Serving Fletcher Bay / Island Center

This area falls under the Bainbridge Island School District (BISD). Based on zoning and neighborhood maps, these are the likely schools:

• Elementary (PK–4): Ordway Elementary School

• Intermediate (Grades 5–6): Sonoji Sakai Intermediate School

• Middle (Grades 7–8): Woodward Middle School

• High School (Grades 9–12):

  • Bainbridge High School (mainstream public)

  • Eagle Harbor High School — BISD’s alternative / independent-study option via Commodore Options.

The Fletcher Bay & Island Center area is a captivating blend of waterfront serenity and rural community life. Whether you’re drawn to peaceful evenings by the bay, forested walks through the Grand Forest, or the practicality of nearby homes and amenities, this neighborhood delivers a strong sense of place. With excellent schools, historic charm, and a slower pace paired with access to island life — it’s a perfect spot for families, nature lovers, and anyone looking for a calm but connected Bainbridge lifestyle.